Drupal and project management

I just made it back from DC and I must say it feels good to be back home in Shanghai. I won't go through the usual review of sessions and congratulations; enough people already gave that kind of feedback for everybody to know it was a blast. This was my first event of that kind and I had the opportunity to chat with a lot of smart people of the industry; a lot of good things came out of it, including the common need for resources related to project management. I hope to find more people interested in helping on that very issue and in the meantime I will do my best to help initiatives such as The CivicActions Estimating Worksheet (thanks a lot Gregory Heller to enlighten me on this) and my very own Project Management tool aka "Ren" (人) that I plan to release soon. I'll try to sum up what I think would be a good direction to head to.

Project Management tool

I attended an interesting BoF with Viktor Kane and a few others in DC and realized the very strong need for project management tools. I insist on "tools" and not "tool" because there are different group of people out here with different needs. There are already several approach to the problem:

  • The project module, that is used to provide the download pages on Drupal.org and integrates with other modules to work with version control system (SVN, CVS), add issue tracking and so on.
  • Project Flow and Tracker, presented by Viktor Kane at DrupalCon DC, that provides a thorough management process relying on roles and user stories, acceptances tests and tasks, which are directly embedded in the website you develop.
  • The many intranets/project management tools that most of Drupal shops have been building to fit their own needs. I think of things like Development Seed's 8 Trees.

The thing is that there is no common approach to the problem; from what I've seen, some users need something closer to Basecamp, some other needs something like the project module, combining version control and issues. What I think is important here is to start committing back what we have, and from there we'll find what are the basic technical bricks we share and we'll be able to put our efforts in common.

I am no different from others, and have myself built a tool that allows me to manage my projects online. I call it "Ren" and it allows me to create a group (Organic Group) for each one of my projects. Each group then gather several types of entries accessible to the project members:

  • Tasks; call it "ticket" or "issue", they all represent the same concept. The main thing here is that I have developed a time tracking module that allows my staff to log the time spent on tasks, this coupled with another of my modules allows me to match actual work loads against estimates. Ultimately, I plan to develop a fairly intelligent system that can predict some well known patterns.
  • Messages; allows me to discuss the project and its details with either other members of the team or the client.
  • Wiki pages; is mainly used to build the documentation that we deliver to the client, but may potentially be used for any type of content that is supposed to be kept for further review.
  • Milestones; simple entries gathering a date and some description blurb. Tasks may relate to a milestone.

One thing to notice here is that the client is using the same platform as the development team; the only differences is that clients can only post messages and comment wiki pages.

I am testing several additional features, including integrating with XMPP; by using the XMPP framework module we can let users discussing projects (OG groups) through their IM (MSN, Google Talk...) or the client embedded in the website. I have two main reasons to do so:

  • I don't like giving away my private IM information to a client, for several reasons (including my will to get a break on weekends),
  • All relevant information that may be exchanged on IM regarding the project is kept on users' machines. Using this architecture, I have the potential for keeping these logs on the website and letting people accessing it through search. If one of your admin decide to change the staging server credentials at 1:00 AM on Friday for example, you won't freak out when trying to access it on Monday morning (when the damn admin is still sleeping after a weekend full of beer).

I have been spending some time putting together an install profile for sharing this with the community, but after discussing with several people at DC last week, I decided to adopt another strategy. The main idea is to keep the main install as general as possible, people will then be able to add features specific to their activity (like integrating SVN/CVS for example). What is sure though is that "Ren" will be shipped with an actual theme; I can't imagine delivering such kind of product without a theme (not Garland again, nooooo!). Stay tuned, I promised to deliver this under a month.

Sharing company documents

As I said before, CivicActions is already sharing resources (I strongly advise you to check on the document linked above, this is a very valuable tool) and after talking with Gregory Heller I am more convinced than ever that building a complete suite of project management related documents, including scoping document, information architecture, wireframes and even contract templates, would make sense. I myself would naturally tend to consider that kind of asset as too private and valuable to be shared outside of the company. However, on a technical level, the Drupal community is already working that way; the bricks that the whole community of professionals use to build their products is for the most part contributed back. This is, in my own opinion, one of the very reasons why our community enjoys such a healthy competition. We often see Drupal shops or individuals from different companies associating to maintain a module. There is no reason that would be different for documents.

My next step on this will be to finalize the latest version of my scoping and information architecture documents and find a place to share these on Drupal.org. I am unsure of the best way to do so; if some of you have advices, please let me know. I also encourage anybody to give a spin to CivicActions' spreadsheet and to give them feedback. You can also join the Project Management group on groups.drupal.org if you wish to discuss such kind of initiative.

Hi, Glad to have found your post. This is an interesting approach and I am with you about what you said: "The thing is that there is no common approach to the problem;". Have you had the occasion to see: : (Basecamp Cloned In Drupal) ? Will follow your developments, Thanks.

I haven't watched the whole video (it's damn slow from China), however my goal here is not to clone Basecamp. I think it is a very interesting case study, however there are things I would like to do differently from Basecamp (I just don't see it as the perfect tool). Be prepared to have some nice shiny statistics exposing some of the metrics pulled out of the system :).

your funny man :)

Thank you for taking the initiative on this! Looking forward to more collaboration among Drupal shops in this area.

thanks for this post, and for sharing your ideas with me at the Zivtech offices post Drupalcon.

i agree with your approach of not mandating the finished product, but sharing the work on the building blocks.

ren looks great, and its on the list of Drupal-based project tracking software that Zivtech will be assessing in the near future.

happy hacking!

http://drupal.org/project/bubbletimer

Cool little module I found a few days ago that lets you do the hour tracking aspect of project management. Has some quirks in terms of workflow but really cool UI / graphing stuff in it. Might be cool to work into everything else you've mentioned.

thanks for your sharing. i am waiting to try it

Thanks for writing this up. I enjoyed speaking with you about our tools and your tools, and I look forward to seeing what you release. I think it would be good for some of the shops that have worked on these types of intranets to get together to compare notes more and consolidate efforts. I'd hate to wait until paris, but if there is no opportunity before then, maybe there could be a code sprint to knock something out?

A sweet pearl just hit the Drupal Project page: Dropbox integration module, I think it's the next step in sharing files between project management team and also to receive (and store securely) files from your customer.

Eegarding assignating task to people. Project module is a good candidate to such project management intranet, but only allows a task to be assignated to one person, do you have a better solution ?

Also regarding calendars, any integration in the sight with google cal or other shared calendar to schedule the project ?

I'm really looking forward to see what your solution will be. Thank you so much for sharing this.

thank you so much

Ren looks to be EXACTLY what I've been looking for...I can't wait to see this released. Please be sure to email me and let me know when you actually do release this, I think it will be perfect for what I'm trying to do at work with my programmer team. (I work for an application service provider) I'm a network engineer and when we do a client implementation, I have a bunch of tasks that go into it but the programmer team needs to know where I'm at in the process of a client setup so they can do their part in the correct orders...crazy I know, but this tool should REALLY help us all with what we need to do internally for setting up our new clients. Thanks!

yes i think so http://drupal.org/project/bubbletimer great modul

just take over STORM and forge it into something awesome(r)?

Well, for having tested storm before I find it very heavy and bloated: not at all the kind of tool I'd use everyday... But if anybody feels like it, the project page is announcing that Storm is looking for a new maintainer; go for it and make it awesome.

I am looking forward to seeing Ren in action. I've messed around with Storm a bit, and like you said in one of the other comments, it's very heavy and bloated.

Good work!

So there are certainly some news since this post - openatrium was released by developmentseed and it looks promising: http://openatrium.com/

From the point of someone who is searching for the "right" pmm tools atm I'd say let's focus on one project - I've seen too many recently ;)

We are actually migrating everything on Open Atrium; we'll release soon our version of that distribution with a custom theme.

This is the great project management tool blog.I think, this tool should really help to all.

Thank you really very good article and good text..

Thanks for your post.Nice webdesign.

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options